Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

The chart

Generous to games, or generous compared with peers?

Each dot is an outlet with at least 15 games on both measures. Right of zero: it ranks games above where Steam players put them. Above zero: it ranks games above the other panel outlets. Dots are each outlet's raw mean gaps; whiskers are their raw 90% intervals, so you can see how much of the spread is noise. The shrunk estimates used everywhere else on the site are in the table below. Hollow dots are platform-branded outlets.

-30-30-20-20-10-1000+10+10+20+20+30+30Nintendo LifePush SquareEurogamerPC GamerIGNScreen RantGame InformerGamesRadar+ STEAM GAP → outlet ranks games above players (percentile points) CONSENSUS GAP → outlet ranks games above other critics

Ranks games above Steam playersRanks games below Steam playersWithin noise on the Steam gap

Swipe the chart sideways to see all of it.

Not shown (too few games): Game Rant, TheGamer, VGC, Pure Xbox. Unscored outlets are excluded by definition.

The same numbers, as strips

OutletSteam gap−40 · 0 · +40Consensus gap−40 · 0 · +40
Eurogamer+5.2n=22−13.3n=28
Game Informer+5.9n=28+2.0n=33
GamesRadar++5.9n=23−4.1n=30
IGN+5.8n=36−0.9n=44
Nintendo Life+4.3n=31−1.7n=22
PC Gamer+5.1n=27−7.2n=23
Push Square+4.7n=34−3.4n=36
Screen Rant+6.1n=27−3.3n=29

Higher than the comparison (players, or the other panel critics)Lower than the comparisonWithin noise: the 90% interval includes zero

Bars show the shrunk gap; the outlined box is its 90% interval. Gray bars are within noise.

Panel-wide gap, by Steam variant

All scored panel reviews pooled; intervals treat games as the independent units.

VariantReviewsGamesMean gap90% interval
Day 30 · filtered · all languages (base)27284+4.5−3.0 to +11.9
Unfiltered (bombs included)27284+4.5−3.0 to +11.9
English only27183+5.3−2.2 to +12.8
Playtime ≥ 2h26882+5.7−1.7 to +13.1
Day 7328101+4.6−2.4 to +11.6
Day 908834+9.5−3.0 to +22.0
Excluding documented non-game bombs27284+4.5−3.0 to +11.9

Patch drift largest moves

Change in Steam's adjusted percent positive from day 7 to day 90 (or to date, once past day 30). Large positive drift alongside a low launch score usually means critics reviewed a broken launch that was later fixed.

GameDay 7LaterDriftCritics
EA SPORTS FC 2754%47%today (day 54)−6.372
Avatar Legends: The Fighting Game82%86%day 90+4.178
Beast of Reincarnation53%57%day 90+3.966
Castlevania: Belmont's Curse74%78%today (day 34)+3.877
SILENT HILL: Townfall66%69%today (day 55)+3.379
METAL GEAR SOLID: MASTER COLLECTION Vol.262%65%today (day 82)+3.090
Valor Mortis78%81%today (day 35)+2.975
Mortal Shell II77%80%day 90+2.782
STAR WARS Zero Company80%83%today (day 82)+2.783
ACE COMBAT 8: WINGS OF THEVE83%85%today (day 47)+2.687
Big Walk93%96%day 90+2.689
Halo: Campaign Evolved63%60%day 90−2.582