Generous to games, or generous compared with peers?
Each dot is an outlet with at least 15 games on both measures. Right of zero: it ranks games above where Steam players put them. Above zero: it ranks games above the other panel outlets. Dots are each outlet's raw mean gaps; whiskers are their raw 90% intervals, so you can see how much of the spread is noise. The shrunk estimates used everywhere else on the site are in the table below. Hollow dots are platform-branded outlets.
Ranks games above Steam playersRanks games below Steam playersWithin noise on the Steam gap
Swipe the chart sideways to see all of it.Not shown (too few games): Game Rant, TheGamer, VGC, Pure Xbox. Unscored outlets are excluded by definition.
The same numbers, as strips
| Outlet | Steam gap | −40 · 0 · +40 | Consensus gap | −40 · 0 · +40 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eurogamer | +5.2n=22 | −13.3n=28 | ||
| Game Informer | +5.9n=28 | +2.0n=33 | ||
| GamesRadar+ | +5.9n=23 | −4.1n=30 | ||
| IGN | +5.8n=36 | −0.9n=44 | ||
| Nintendo Life | +4.3n=31 | −1.7n=22 | ||
| PC Gamer | +5.1n=27 | −7.2n=23 | ||
| Push Square | +4.7n=34 | −3.4n=36 | ||
| Screen Rant | +6.1n=27 | −3.3n=29 |
Higher than the comparison (players, or the other panel critics)Lower than the comparisonWithin noise: the 90% interval includes zero
Bars show the shrunk gap; the outlined box is its 90% interval. Gray bars are within noise.
Panel-wide gap, by Steam variant
All scored panel reviews pooled; intervals treat games as the independent units.
| Variant | Reviews | Games | Mean gap | 90% interval |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Day 30 · filtered · all languages (base) | 272 | 84 | +4.5 | −3.0 to +11.9 |
| Unfiltered (bombs included) | 272 | 84 | +4.5 | −3.0 to +11.9 |
| English only | 271 | 83 | +5.3 | −2.2 to +12.8 |
| Playtime ≥ 2h | 268 | 82 | +5.7 | −1.7 to +13.1 |
| Day 7 | 328 | 101 | +4.6 | −2.4 to +11.6 |
| Day 90 | 88 | 34 | +9.5 | −3.0 to +22.0 |
| Excluding documented non-game bombs | 272 | 84 | +4.5 | −3.0 to +11.9 |
Patch drift largest moves
Change in Steam's adjusted percent positive from day 7 to day 90 (or to date, once past day 30). Large positive drift alongside a low launch score usually means critics reviewed a broken launch that was later fixed.
| Game | Day 7 | Later | Drift | Critics |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EA SPORTS FC 27 | 54% | 47%today (day 54) | −6.3 | 72 |
| Avatar Legends: The Fighting Game | 82% | 86%day 90 | +4.1 | 78 |
| Beast of Reincarnation | 53% | 57%day 90 | +3.9 | 66 |
| Castlevania: Belmont's Curse | 74% | 78%today (day 34) | +3.8 | 77 |
| SILENT HILL: Townfall | 66% | 69%today (day 55) | +3.3 | 79 |
| METAL GEAR SOLID: MASTER COLLECTION Vol.2 | 62% | 65%today (day 82) | +3.0 | 90 |
| Valor Mortis | 78% | 81%today (day 35) | +2.9 | 75 |
| Mortal Shell II | 77% | 80%day 90 | +2.7 | 82 |
| STAR WARS Zero Company | 80% | 83%today (day 82) | +2.7 | 83 |
| ACE COMBAT 8: WINGS OF THEVE | 83% | 85%today (day 47) | +2.6 | 87 |
| Big Walk | 93% | 96%day 90 | +2.6 | 89 |
| Halo: Campaign Evolved | 63% | 60%day 90 | −2.5 | 82 |