Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

The panel · platform-branded (PlayStation)

Push Square

Score scale 0–10. 55 game reviews in the window. www.pushsquare.com

Steam gap

+4.7

Mean of (score percentile − Steam day-30 percentile), shrunk toward the panel. 90% interval −0.1 to +9.5. 34 games; raw mean −4.2. Higher than 19% of eligible outlets.

Consensus gap

−3.4

Same calculation against the mean of the other panel outlets. Within noise. 90% interval −10.1 to +3.3. 36 games; raw mean −4.1. Higher than 41% of eligible outlets.

How to read it

Positive: this outlet ranks games higher than players (left) or than its peers (middle). If the Steam gap is high but the consensus gap is near zero, the whole press is more generous than players, not this outlet in particular.

Robustness strip

The Steam gap recomputed with each alternative player measure. A finding counts only if its sign survives every variant with enough games.

Not distinguishable from zero (5 of 6 variants had 15+ games)

Conditional gaps

How far this outlet moves from its own baseline on a kind of game, in percentile points, shrunk toward zero. Shown only with at least 8 games. Called a "difference" unless the 90% interval excludes zero against both players and critics.

Categoryvs. Steamvs. criticsReading
Major-publisher (AAA/AA) releases+1.790%: −2.8 to +6.2 · n=24−0.690%: −4.8 to +3.7 · n=26not distinguishable from zero
Indie-tagged releasesn=5n=4not shown (fewer than 8 games)
Likely console exclusives (not on Steam)No Steam score exists for these games, so only the consensus version can be computed.—n=2not shown (fewer than 8 games)

Bylines with 8+ scored reviews

Listed alphabetically by surname, not ranked. Figures describe published reviews only. 12 other bylines with fewer than 8 scored reviews are not shown.

BylineReviewsMean score /100vs. other critics
Aaron Bayne1172−8.3n=7
Robert Ramsey1182+13.6n=8

Disclosure audit

Ethics or standards policy
Push Square Editorial Ethics Policy (checked 2026-11-17)
States review-copy source
96% (53 of 55)
Affiliate disclosure on the page
2% (1 of 55)

Parsed from each review page's text (scripts, navigation and footer removed). "Review-copy source" means a line such as "code provided by the publisher" or "we bought our copy".

Every review in the window

Game / headlineBylineScorevs. criticsDate
TANUKI: Pon's SummerMini Review: Tanuki: Pon's Summer (PS5) - Easily One of 2026's Most Charming AdventuresRobert Ramsey8/10+20.82026-11-16
Shrek 2 RemasteredMini Review: Shrek 2 Remastered (PS5) - Far Far Away Gets an All-Star MakeoverSam Comrie7/10—2026-11-13
Barbie RewindMini Review: Barbie Rewind (PS5) - Fab Outer Layer Brings This Retro Ensemble TogetherStephen Tailby7/10—2026-11-11
Warhammer SurvivorsMini Review: Warhammer Survivors (PS5) - Absurdly Addictive Crossover Is a Match Made in Bullet HellRobert Ramsey9/10+64.12026-11-10
Godzilla: Destroy All Monsters Melee RemasteredMini Review: Godzilla: Destroy All Monsters Melee Remastered (PS5) - Nostalgic Kaiju Brawls in This Fun But MeGraham Banas7/10+7.02026-11-04
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4Review: Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 (PS5) - Same Old Multiplayer Drags Down Stellar PackageAaron Bayne7/10−52.22026-10-28
Silver PinesReview: Silver Pines (PS5) - Lynchian Metroidvania Is a Cut AboveAaron Bayne8/10—2026-10-27
Phantom Blade ZeroReview: Phantom Blade Zero (PS5) - One of the Generation's Greatest Action ExperiencesLiam Croft9/10−3.22026-10-26
FINAL FANTASY RESONANCEReview: Final Fantasy Resonance (PS5) - Square's Series Returns to Its Roots to Fantastic EffectRobert Ramsey8/10+2.42026-10-20
Stupid Never DiesReview: Stupid Never Dies (PS5) - Toilet-Flushing, Monster-Munching Roguelite Stands Out in a Stacked GenreSammy Barker7/10+25.42026-10-19
Toy Story 3 Complete EditionMini Review: Toy Story 3 Complete Edition (PS5) - An All-Time Great Movie Tie-In Gets a Fresh Lick of PaintGraham Banas7/10—2026-10-14
Toy Story: Retro RoundupMini Review: Toy Story: Retro Roundup (PS5) - This Fun Toy Box Provides a Nostalgic BuzzJohn Hansen7/10—2026-10-14
Tales of Eternia RemasteredReview: Tales of Eternia Remastered (PS5) - Classic PlayStation RPG Shows Its AgeGeorge Yang7/10—2026-10-14
Planet Zoo 2Review: Planet Zoo 2 (PS5) - Sublime Wildlife Management Sim Is Frontier at Its FinestJames Watson9/10+47.82026-10-13
Castlevania: Belmont's CurseReview: Castlevania: Belmont's Curse (PS5) - The Classic Series Returns in a Perfectly Fine MetroidvaniaStephen Tailby7/10−23.62026-10-13
Valor MortisReview: Valor Mortis (PS5) - Imperial Ambitions, Largely RealisedKhayl Adam8/10+20.82026-10-12
Clive Barker's Hellraiser: RevivalReview: Hellraiser: Revival (PS5) - Faithful Adaptation Let Down by Severe Gameplay WoesAaron Bayne5/10−5.02026-10-08
Dragon's Dogma 2: Dark ArisenReview: Dragon's Dogma 2: Dark Arisen (PS5) - Epic Expansion Is Peak Dragon's DogmaRobert Ramsey9/10+25.32026-10-07
Order of the Sinking StarReview: Order of the Sinking Star (PS5) - Jon Blow's Huge Sokoban Design Mixtape Made Me WearyStephen Tailby6/10−64.12026-10-07
Dune: AwakeningReview: Dune: Awakening (PS5) - What a Time to Be a DunerAaron Bayne8/10—2026-10-05
Kingdom Hearts Collection I~IIIMini Review: Kingdom Hearts Collection I~III (PS5) - Great Value for Newcomers in This (Almost) Complete PackaJaimie Ditchfield7/10—2026-10-05
STAR WARS: Galactic RacerReview: Star Wars: Galactic Racer (PS5) - This Ridiculously Good Racer Is in a Galactic League of Its OwnSammy Barker9/10+2.92026-10-02
Ghost of Yotei: Complete EditionReview: Ghost of Yotei: Complete Edition (PS5) - Atsu Shines in Story DLC, But Most Wanted Mode Steals the ShoRobert Ramsey8/10—2026-10-01
End of AbyssReview: End of Abyss (PS5) - This Delectably Dark Metroidvania Forces You to Look CloserAaron Bayne8/10+37.12026-09-30
DYNASTY WARRIORS 3: Complete Edition RemasteredMini Review: Dynasty Warriors 3: Complete Edition Remastered (PS5) - A Strong Case for More Musou RevivalsRobert Ramsey7/10—2026-09-30
Train Sim World 7Review: Train Sim World 7 (PS5) - A Familiar Journey with a Few New StopsSammy Barker7/10—2026-09-28
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt — RemasteredReview: The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Remastered (PS5) - How to Improve a MasterpieceRobert Ramsey10/10+5.52026-09-28
ACE COMBAT 8: WINGS OF THEVEReview: Ace Combat 8: Wings of Theve (PS5) - The Series Lands Its Most Confident Entry YetStephen Tailby8/10−36.32026-09-25
SILENT HILL: TownfallReview: Silent Hill: Townfall (PS5) - Dated Bite-Sized Horror... in a Good WayLiam Croft7/10−33.82026-09-21
CONTROL ResonantReview: Control Resonant (PS5) - A Wildly Inventive and Drop-Dead Gorgeous SequelAaron Bayne8/10+1.42026-09-18
Trails in the Sky 2nd ChapterReview: Trails in the Sky 2nd Chapter (PS5) - Quite Possibly One of the Best RPG Sequels Ever MadeRobert Ramsey9/10−15.52026-09-16
MewgenicsMini Review: Mewgenics (PS5) - The Best Roguelike Since The Binding of IsaacSimon Fitzgerald9/10—2026-09-14
Marvel's WolverineReview: Marvel's Wolverine (PS5) - The Ultimate Wolverine SimulatorLiam Croft8/10+35.12026-09-10
No More Room in Hell 2Mini Review: No More Room in Hell 2 (PS5) - This Co-op Shooter Makes Zombies Scary AgainAaron Bayne7/10—2026-09-09
Aliens: Fireteam Elite 2Review: Aliens: Fireteam Elite 2 (PS5) - A Deeply Disappointing Downgrade of a SequelAaron Bayne4/10−17.42026-09-07
SPRAWL zeroMini Review: Sprawl Zero (PS5) - A Fun Blast of PS2 Shooter NostalgiaAaron Bayne7/10—2026-09-07
HOT WHEELS Infinite RushReview: Hot Wheels: Infinite Rush (PS5) - A Solid Arcade Racer with an Open World It Doesn't NeedStephen Tailby6/10−8.02026-09-06
STAR WARS Zero CompanyReview: Star Wars Zero Company (PS5) - A Perfect Pairing of Licence and Genre Imperfectly ExecutedStephen Tailby7/10−48.12026-09-04
Big WalkReview: Big Walk (PS5) - An Ingenious Co-Op Experience Unlike Anything Else on PS5Aaron Bayne9/10−5.32026-09-01
The Blood of DawnwalkerReview: The Blood of Dawnwalker (PS5) - A Fang-Tastic Vampire RPG Held Back by Toothless CombatRobert Ramsey7/10−17.52026-08-31
Onimusha: Way of the SwordReview: Onimusha: Way of the Sword (PS5) - Capcom Delivers a Masterclass in Samurai ActionRobert Ramsey9/10+23.32026-08-31
Resonance: A Plague Tale LegacyReview: Resonance: A Plague Tale Legacy (PS5) - Solid Story Game without the RatsLiam Croft7/10−17.52026-08-26
METAL GEAR SOLID: MASTER COLLECTION Vol.2Review: Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 2 (PS5) - MGS 4 Is Finally Free from PS3, and It's the Best IJohn Cal McCormick8/10−46.52026-08-21
BRIGANDINE ABYSSReview: Brigandine Abyss (PS5) - A Tactical RPG That's No Fire Emblem, But Still Mildly EntertainingJohn Cal McCormick6/10—2026-08-20
Starsand IslandReview: Starsand Island (PS5) - This Anime Life Sim Should Be Your Next Cosy GameJames Watson7/10—2026-08-18
Mortal Shell IIReview: Mortal Shell 2 (PS5) - An Ingeniously Playful Take on the Dark Souls FormulaAaron Bayne8/10−17.02026-08-18
The Sinking City 2Review: The Sinking City 2 (PS5) - An Admirable Resident Evil-Lite ExperienceLiam Croft7/10−5.22026-08-17
MARVEL Tōkon: Fighting SoulsReview: Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls (PS5) - The Most Exciting Fighting Game in YearsSammy Barker9/10+9.02026-08-10
Beast of ReincarnationReview: Beast of Reincarnation (PS5) - Pokémon Dev's Flower Power Action RPG Is Nearly in Full BloomStephen Tailby7/10+15.22026-08-04
DRAGON BALL: Sparking! ZEROReview: Dragon Ball: Sparking! Zero - Super Limit-Breaking NEO (PS5) - Disappointing Solo Mode Scuppers a BulkRobert Ramsey6/10—2026-07-30
Avatar Legends: The Fighting GameMini Review: Avatar Legends: The Fighting Game (PS5) - Solid Foundation Bending to GreatnessSammy Barker6/10−61.02026-07-29
Kusan: City of WolvesMini Review: Kusan: City of Wolves (PS5) - Fast-Paced Carnage in This Tough Hotline Miami-LikeJaimie Ditchfield7/10—2026-07-28
Halo: Campaign EvolvedReview: Halo: Campaign Evolved (PS5) - Xbox Icon Returns to Glory in This Heroic RemakeLiam Croft9/10+23.32026-07-23
PalworldReview: Palworld (PS5) - Expansive Catch 'Em All Gives Pokémon a Run for Its MoneySimon Fitzgerald8/10+33.02026-07-21
70's-style Robot Anime Geppy-XMini Review: 70's-style Robot Anime Geppy-X (PS5) - Zany PS1 Shooter Is a Real TreatSammy Barker7/10—2026-07-20