Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

The panel · general outlet

VGC

Score scale 1–5 stars. 24 game reviews in the window. www.videogameschronicle.com

Steam gap

n=13

Muted: fewer than 15 games. Raw mean +14.2 pts.

Consensus gap

−4.7

Same calculation against the mean of the other panel outlets. Within noise. 90% interval −12.7 to +3.3. 22 games; raw mean −7.6. Higher than 23% of eligible outlets.

How to read it

Scale note: this outlet uses a five-point scale, so a 3/5 counts as 60/100 and a 4/5 as 80/100. Part of any consensus gap reflects how a coarse star scale maps onto 0–100, not only how harsh or generous its critics are.

Positive: this outlet ranks games higher than players (left) or than its peers (middle). If the Steam gap is high but the consensus gap is near zero, the whole press is more generous than players, not this outlet in particular.

Robustness strip

The Steam gap recomputed with each alternative player measure. A finding counts only if its sign survives every variant with enough games.

Conditional gaps

How far this outlet moves from its own baseline on a kind of game, in percentile points, shrunk toward zero. Shown only with at least 8 games. Called a "difference" unless the 90% interval excludes zero against both players and critics.

Categoryvs. Steamvs. criticsReading
Major-publisher (AAA/AA) releases+0.590%: −4.3 to +5.2 · n=12±0.090%: −4.5 to +4.6 · n=20not distinguishable from zero
Indie-tagged releasesn=1n=2not shown (fewer than 8 games)
Likely console exclusives (not on Steam)No Steam score exists for these games, so only the consensus version can be computed.—n=5not shown (fewer than 8 games)

Bylines with 8+ scored reviews

Listed alphabetically by surname, not ranked. Figures describe published reviews only. 4 other bylines with fewer than 8 scored reviews are not shown.

BylineReviewsMean score /100vs. other critics
Jordan Middler880+7.2n=7

Disclosure audit

Ethics or standards policy
VGC's review policy explained (checked 2026-11-17)
States review-copy source
0% (0 of 24)
Affiliate disclosure on the page
100% (24 of 24)

Parsed from each review page's text (scripts, navigation and footer removed). "Review-copy source" means a line such as "code provided by the publisher" or "we bought our copy".

Every review in the window

Game / headlineBylineScorevs. criticsDate
TANUKI: Pon's SummerTanuki: Pon’s Summer review: A charming delivery sim with the guts to take on Zelda and GTA head-to-head | VGCChris Scullion4/5+20.82026-11-09
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TimeZelda: Ocarina of Time Remake Review: Nintendo’s timeless masterpiece | VGCAndy Robinson5/5−0.52026-11-04
Phantom Blade ZeroPhantom Blade Zero review: A damn good action game that shouldn’t be ignored | VGCDave Aubrey4/5−36.32026-10-26
Stupid Never DiesStupid Never Dies review: Capcom veterans resurrect the PS3 era with a quirky, off-beat action game | VGCJordan Middler3/5+9.42026-10-23
Nintendo Switch Sports ResortNintendo Switch Sports Resort review: The most feature-packed Nintendo sports game yet | VGCChris Scullion4/5−5.72026-10-20
FINAL FANTASY RESONANCEFinal Fantasy Resonance Review: A nostalgic JRPG limited by its mobile origins | VGCDave Aubrey3/5−48.82026-10-20
Castlevania: Belmont's CurseCastlevania Belmont’s Curse review: The first new 2D entry in 13 years looks incredible but lacks teeth | VGCChris Scullion3/5−41.62026-10-13
STAR WARS: Galactic RacerStar Wars Galactic Racer review: Somehow, Burnout returns in a modern racing classic | VGCJordan Middler5/5+19.92026-10-02
Ghost of Yotei: Complete EditionGhost of Yotei Complete Edition review: An expansion worth returning for | VGCJordan Middler4/5—2026-10-01
Gears of War: E-DayGears of War E-Day campaign review: An absolute blast, even if it focuses on commotion over emotion | VGCChris Scullion4/5−36.32026-10-01
SILENT HILL: TownfallSilent Hill Townfall review: Outstanding horror marred by infuriating stealth | VGCChris Scullion3/5−48.82026-09-21
EA SPORTS FC 27EA Sports FC 27 review: The first major new mode in years makes EA’s latest more than a typical annual update Chris Scullion4/5+30.02026-09-18
CONTROL ResonantControl Resonant review: Remedy gambles on a genre change in one of its most impressive games ever | VGCJordan Middler5/5+52.62026-09-18
Fire Emblem: Fortune's WeaveFire Emblem Fortune’s Weave Review: Nintendo’s most ambitious RPG yet is an incredible triumph | VGCDave Aubrey5/5+17.92026-09-16
Marvel's WolverineMarvel’s Wolverine Review: Uninspired gameplay leaves Logan feeling declawed despite a strong narrative | VGCJordan Middler3/5−12.12026-09-10
Onimusha: Way of the SwordOnimusha Way of the Sword review: A series reborn with great fights, but too many wrong modern lessons | VGCJordan Middler3/5−63.12026-08-31
The Blood of DawnwalkerThe Blood of Dawnwalker Review: Witcher 3 veterans prove a focused RPG beats a bloated one | VGCJordan Middler4/5+20.82026-08-31
STAR WARS Zero CompanyStar Wars Zero Company Review: Exceptional strategic adventure shows what Star Wars is capable of | VGCJade King4/5−20.02026-08-26
METAL GEAR SOLID: MASTER COLLECTION Vol.2Metal Gear Solid: Master Collection Vol. 2 review: Come for Metal Gear Solid 4, stay for two handheld classicsJordan Middler5/5+23.02026-08-21
Beast of ReincarnationBeast of Reincarnation review: Endearing characters and combat wrapped in a disappointingly dull journey | VGCDave Aubrey3/5−1.82026-08-04
PalworldPalworld 1.0 review: A patently pleasing adventure held back by busywork | VGCDave Aubrey3/5−33.52026-07-29
Rhythm Heaven GrooveRhythm Heaven Groove review: Nintendo’s musical paradise makes a much needed return | VGCDave Aubrey5/5—2026-07-24
Halo: Campaign EvolvedHalo Campaign Evolved Review: An Unreal excuse to revisit a classic | VGCAndy Robinson5/5+42.42026-07-23
Splatoon RaidersSplatoon Raiders review: A challenging, all-out action game that’s well worth 50 squid | VGCChris Scullion4/5−26.12026-07-21