Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

The panel · general outlet

Screen Rant

Score scale 0–10. 55 game reviews in the window. screenrant.com

Steam gap

+6.1

Mean of (score percentile − Steam day-30 percentile), shrunk toward the panel. 90% interval +1.6 to +10.7. 27 games; raw mean +8.5. Higher than 94% of eligible outlets.

Consensus gap

−3.3

Same calculation against the mean of the other panel outlets. Within noise. 90% interval −10.6 to +4.1. 29 games; raw mean −4.2. Higher than 50% of eligible outlets.

How to read it

Positive: this outlet ranks games higher than players (left) or than its peers (middle). If the Steam gap is high but the consensus gap is near zero, the whole press is more generous than players, not this outlet in particular.

Robustness strip

The Steam gap recomputed with each alternative player measure. A finding counts only if its sign survives every variant with enough games.

Finding: the 90% interval excludes zero and the sign survives every usable variant (5 of 6 variants had 15+ games)

Conditional gaps

How far this outlet moves from its own baseline on a kind of game, in percentile points, shrunk toward zero. Shown only with at least 8 games. Called a "difference" unless the 90% interval excludes zero against both players and critics.

Categoryvs. Steamvs. criticsReading
Major-publisher (AAA/AA) releases+4.590%: +0.5 to +8.5 · n=17−0.190%: −4.5 to +4.2 · n=22difference (vs Steam only)
Indie-tagged releasesn=6n=3not shown (fewer than 8 games)
Likely console exclusives (not on Steam)No Steam score exists for these games, so only the consensus version can be computed.—n=3not shown (fewer than 8 games)

Bylines with 8+ scored reviews

Listed alphabetically by surname, not ranked. Figures describe published reviews only. 16 other bylines with fewer than 8 scored reviews are not shown.

BylineReviewsMean score /100vs. other critics
Chris Carter1279−11.5n=11

Disclosure audit

Ethics or standards policy
Valnet Editorial Standards (plus a review policy) (checked 2026-11-17)
States review-copy source
5% (3 of 55)
Affiliate disclosure on the page
0% (0 of 55)

Parsed from each review page's text (scripts, navigation and footer removed). "Review-copy source" means a line such as "code provided by the publisher" or "we bought our copy".

Every review in the window

Game / headlineBylineScorevs. criticsDate
Milki DeliveryMilki Delivery Review - Possibly The Next A Short HikeCarrie Lambertsen8/10—2026-11-16
The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ Review - Refining A Modern ClassicBrandon Zachary9/10—2026-11-12
The Good Daughter: Peacock’s Trauma-Saturated Mess Wastes Its Stellar Cast |The Good Daughter: Peacock’s Trauma-Saturated Mess Wastes Its Stellar Cast | ReviewLiz Hersey3/10—2026-11-11
Warhammer SurvivorsWarhammer Survivors Review: Late to the Game But Packed With BulletsLeo Faierman6/10−46.82026-11-10
FarawayFaraway Review: Worth the 16-Year WaitBrandon Zachary9/10—2026-11-09
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TimeThe Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time Review - A Link To A MasterpieceChris Carter9/10−17.52026-11-04
CBS Rewrites Ghosts’ Fundamental Woodstone Laws In Halloween 6 |CBS Rewrites Ghosts’ Fundamental Woodstone Laws In Halloween 6 | ReviewMads Misasi8/10—2026-10-30
Virtue and a SledgehammerVirtue and a Sledgehammer Review: This Is Meant To Hurt YouLeo Faierman8/10—2026-10-27
Phantom Blade ZeroPhantom Blade Zero Review: A Martial Arts Feast for the Eyes and EarsLeo Faierman9/10−3.22026-10-26
Warrior Cats: Clans of the ForestWarrior Cats: Clans of the Forest Review - Bringing The Books To LifeAustin King7/10—2026-10-23
FINAL FANTASY RESONANCEFinal Fantasy Resonance Review - Close To Classic Final FantasyChris Carter9/10+33.52026-10-20
Nintendo Switch Sports ResortNintendo Switch Sports Resort Review - 12 Sports For The Whole FamilyAustin King8/10−5.72026-10-20
Stupid Never DiesStupid Never Dies Review: A Zombie Roguelite Struggle SessionLeo Faierman4/10−3.12026-10-19
CoD: Modern Warfare 4 Has A Thrilling Campaign, Exciting DMZ, And Strong MultiplayerCall Of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 Campaign Review - Somehow, The Glory Days ReturnedJames Lynch8/10—2026-10-19
Penguin ColonyPenguin Colony Review - Sliding, Not SoaringBen Brosofsky6/10—2026-10-16
The Jackbox Party Pack 12Jackbox Party Pack 12 Review - A Pack In Search Of A StarBen Brosofsky6/10—2026-10-15
Castlevania: Belmont's CurseCastlevania: Belmont's Curse Review - Drac Is Back In Bloody Good FashionBen Brosofsky8/10+8.62026-10-13
Bluey's Happy SnapsBluey's Happy Snaps Review - Taking Advice From A Cartoon DogChris Carter7/10—2026-10-12
Total War: SHOGUN 2 Complete EditionTotal War: SHOGUN 2 Complete Edition Review - The Best Total War Game Gets Even BetterJames Lynch9/10—2026-10-12
The Remarried Empress: The Best K-Drama Of 2026 Is Officially Here |The Remarried Empress: The Best K-Drama Of 2026 Is Officially Here | ReviewShealyn Scott9/10—2026-10-10
Treasure Island: A Bland Adaptation That Strays Too Far From The Classic Pirate Tale |Treasure Island: A Bland Adaptation That Strays Too Far From The Classic Pirate Tale | ReviewGrant Hermanns4/10—2026-10-09
Dragon's Dogma 2: Dark ArisenDragon's Dogma 2: Dark Arisen Review - More Of A Pawn Than A QueenKyle Gratton7/10−54.22026-10-07
Order of the Sinking StarOrder of the Sinking Star Review: A Maxed-Out Puzzle Game MasterpieceLeo Faierman9/10+64.12026-10-07
Clive Barker's Hellraiser: RevivalClive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival Review - An Absolute Nightmare (In The Best Way Possible)Nicholas Becher8/10+47.32026-10-07
STAR WARS: Galactic RacerStar Wars: Galactic Racer Review - Fuse Games' Run-Based Racer Is An Instant Genre ClassicJames Lynch8/10−36.32026-10-02
Gears of War: E-DayGears of War: E-Day Review - Play It Again, DomChris Carter9/10+2.92026-10-01
TOEM 2TOEM 2 Review - Quite Possibly The Best Cozy Game Of The YearAustin King9/10+23.32026-09-28
Kill JackieKill Jackie Review: Catherine Zeta-Jones Stuns In AMC+'s Cinematic Revenge ThrillerCher Thompson8/10—2026-09-28
Well DwellerWell Dweller Tweaks A Classic Formula To Maximum EffectBrandon Zachary9/10—2026-09-26
ACE COMBAT 8: WINGS OF THEVEAce Combat 8: Wings of Theve Review - Mostly Ace, Lots Of CombatChris Carter8/10−36.32026-09-25
SILENT HILL: TownfallSilent Hill: Townfall Review - Not The Hill You'd ExpectChris Carter7/10−33.82026-09-21
CONTROL ResonantControl Resonant Review: A Rabbit Hole For Remedy's ArtistryKyle Gratton9/10+33.52026-09-18
TCG Card Shop Simulator PS5TCG Card Shop Simulator PS5 Review: "I Just Want To Open All The Packs!"Carrie Lambertsen8/10—2026-09-17
Dragon Quest Heroes: Torneko's Mystery Dungeon -Classic HD-Dragon Quest Heroes: Torneko's Mystery Dungeon-Classic HD- ReviewAustin King7/10—2026-09-16
Fire Emblem: Fortune's WeaveFire Emblem: Fortune's Weave Review - A Mix Of Old And NewChris Carter8/10−40.42026-09-16
High Value TargetHigh Value Target Review: A Refreshingly Nuanced Iraq War Drama That Lacks SuspenseGuy Howie6/10—2026-09-11
Agatha Christie's Tommy & TuppenceAgatha Christie's Tommy & Tuppence Review: Murder & Romance Collide In BritBox's Delightful 21st-Century AdaptEl Kuiper7/10—2026-09-10
NBA 2K27Review: NBA 2K27 - A Fine Time To Return To The CourtChris Carter7/10+11.12026-09-07
HOT WHEELS Infinite RushHot Wheels Infinite Rush Review: Forza Horizon But Make It ToysCarrie Lambertsen8/10+44.32026-09-06
The Drop: A Snowfall SagaThe Drop: A Snowfall Saga Review - FX’s Spinoff Enters A Thrilling New Era InGuy Howie7/10—2026-09-01
Onimusha: Way of the SwordOnimusha: Way of the Sword Review - A Capcom Classic ReturnsChris Carter9/10+23.32026-08-31
The Blood of DawnwalkerThe Blood Of Dawnwalker Review: Fresh Blood & Familiar BonesNicholas Becher8/10+20.82026-08-31
STAR WARS Zero CompanyStar Wars Zero Company Review: A Tactics Game Of Galactic ProportionsKyle Gratton8/10−20.02026-08-26
Mortal Shell IIMortal Shell 2 Review: The Joy of Feeling OP In This Satisfying Soulslike SequelLeo Faierman9/10+23.32026-08-17
The Lord of the Rings: War in the North - Legacy EditionThe Lord of the Rings: War in the North - Legacy Edition - A Warm Embrace From An Old FriendJames Lynch7/10—2026-08-15
Madden NFL 27Madden NFL 27 Review - Impressive Franchise Return Marred By The Same Old IssuesJames Lynch7/10−5.22026-08-14
MARVEL Tōkon: Fighting SoulsMarvel Tokon: Fighting Souls Review - An Assembly Of ChampionsMatthew Danielson8/10−26.12026-08-09
Pokémon Pokopia: Bubbly Basin DLCPokémon Pokopia: Bubbly Basin DLC Review - Makes A SplashCarrie Lambertsen10/10—2026-08-07
The Ninth JediThe Ninth Jedi Review: Star Wars' First Full Anime Series Is A Stunning TriumphEl Kuiper8/10—2026-08-05
Capy CastawayCapy Castaway Review - A Truly Heartwarming ExperienceCarrie Lambertsen6/10—2026-08-04
Beast of ReincarnationBeast of Reincarnation Review - Game Freak Stretches Its Legs Beyond PokemonChris Carter7/10+15.22026-08-04
Big WalkBig Walk Review - A Road Worth TravelingChris Carter8/10−42.52026-08-03
Shards of OrderShards of Order Review: A Brutal But Balanced RPG DeckbuilderLeo Faierman9/10—2026-07-28
Halo: Campaign EvolvedHalo: Campaign Evolved Review: A Master Foundation With Modern OdditiesChris Carter7/10−42.02026-07-23
Avatar Legends: The Fighting GameAvatar Legends: The Fighting Game Review - Balance Between All ElementsMatthew Danielson8/10+7.52026-07-22