Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

Release

Penguin Colony

Fellow Traveller · developer ORIGAME DIGITAL · released 2026-10-16 (steam) · tier: Indie. Steam store page · Metacritic (link only)

Critics (panel)

70

Mean of 2 scored reviews, 0–100. Percentile needs three scores.

Steam players

87%

Adjusted % positive, 366 reviews (day 30). 53rd percentile of this year.

Gap

—

Critic percentile minus player percentile.

The reviews, side by side

Outlet / bylineHeadlineScorevs. other criticsDate
PC GamerTed LitchfieldPenguin Colony Review80/10080/100—2026-10-24
Screen RantBen BrosofskyPenguin Colony Review - Sliding, Not Soaring6/1060/100—2026-10-16
Rock Paper ShotgunEdwin Evans-ThirlwellPenguin Colony review - the least expected Soulslike you'll play, and a cracking parody of Lovecraftian empiresunscored—2026-10-16

"vs. other critics" is the review's percentile minus the percentile of the other panel outlets' mean for this game (needs two other scores). Not reviewed in the window by: IGN, GamesRadar+, Eurogamer, Game Informer, Game Rant, TheGamer, VGC, Push Square, Nintendo Life, Pure Xbox, Kotaku, The Verge, GameSpot.

Steam, measured several ways

Cumulative reviews from release to each day mark. "Filtered" excludes reviews Steam flags as off-topic review bombs; "unfiltered" keeps them. Steam snapshot of 2026-11-17; reviews can be edited later, so we save a raw snapshot every day.

WindowFiltered, all languagesUnfilteredEnglish onlyPlaytime ≥ 2h
Day 783%adj 83% · 17583%adj 83% · 17584%adj 84% · 16186%adj 86% · 137
Day 3087%adj 87% · 36687%adj 87% · 36687%adj 87% · 33189%adj 89% · 317
Day 90————
To date87%adj 87% · 37387%adj 87% · 37387%adj 87% · 338—

Patch drift: +3.7 points of adjusted % positive from day 7 (83%) to today (day 32) (87%). Little change since launch.