Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

The panel

Outlets, measured two ways

Steam gap: how much higher this outlet ranks games than Steam players do. Consensus gap: how much higher it ranks them than the other panel outlets do. Both in percentile points, shrunk toward the panel for small samples, shown only with 15+ games. Listed in panel order, not ranked.

OutletReviewsSteam gapConsensus gapRobustness
IGNGeneral · 0–10 63+5.890%: +1.1 to +10.5 −0.990%: −5.8 to +4.0 within noise
PC GamerGeneral · 0–100 32+5.190%: +0.3 to +9.9 −7.290%: −14.6 to +0.3 within noise
GamesRadar+General · 0–5 stars 39+5.990%: +0.9 to +10.8 −4.190%: −11.3 to +3.1 within noise
EurogamerGeneral · 1–5 stars 32+5.290%: +0.3 to +10.1 −13.390%: −19.8 to −6.7 within noise
Game InformerGeneral · 0–10 43+5.990%: +1.1 to +10.8 +2.090%: −3.4 to +7.4 within noise
Game RantGeneral · 0–10 23n=13 −0.890%: −7.7 to +6.0
TheGamerGeneral · 0–10 26n=14 +3.990%: −3.2 to +11.0
Screen RantGeneral · 0–10 55+6.190%: +1.6 to +10.7 −3.390%: −10.6 to +4.1 finding
VGCGeneral · 1–5 stars 24n=13 −4.790%: −12.7 to +3.3
Push SquarePlatform: PlayStation · 0–10 55+4.790%: −0.1 to +9.5 −3.490%: −10.1 to +3.3 within noise
Nintendo LifePlatform: Nintendo · 0–10 82+4.390%: −0.5 to +9.1 −1.790%: −8.9 to +5.4 within noise
Pure XboxPlatform: Xbox · 0–10 5n=4 n=5
Rock Paper ShotgunGeneral · unscored 12— —
KotakuGeneral · unscored 20— —
The VergeGeneral · unscored 10— —
GameSpotGeneral · 0–10 (not readable: bot wall) 4— —

Disclosure audit

Whether each outlet publishes an ethics or standards policy on its own site, and the share of its reviews in the window that state where the review copy came from or disclose affiliate links on the page. Measured from public pages only; no claims about individuals.

OutletEthics policyReview-copy sourceAffiliate disclosure
IGNYes0%0 of 6329%18 of 63
PC GamerYes0%0 of 32100%32 of 32
GamesRadar+Yes95%37 of 39100%39 of 39
EurogamerYes62%20 of 32100%32 of 32
Game InformerYes0%0 of 430%0 of 43
Game RantYes0%0 of 230%0 of 23
TheGamerYes0%0 of 260%0 of 26
Screen RantYes5%3 of 550%0 of 55
VGCYes0%0 of 24100%24 of 24
Push SquareYes96%53 of 552%1 of 55
Nintendo LifeYes94%77 of 8249%40 of 82
Pure XboxYes100%5 of 50%0 of 5
Rock Paper ShotgunYes0%0 of 12100%12 of 12
KotakuYes0%0 of 200%0 of 20
The VergeYes0%0 of 100%0 of 10
GameSpotNot found——