Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

The widest split this edition

Critics rate Clive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival well below where Steam players put it

The panel's scored reviews average 60 out of 100, which ranks at the 5th percentile of this year's reviewed releases. Steam players' adjusted 93% positive ranks at the 74th percentile. That is a gap of −69.3 percentile points.

A gap is not a verdict on who is right. Players and critics weigh different things, and Steam reacts to prices, ports and politics as well as to the game.

Also split

Gears of War: E-Day

Critics +56.2 percentile points vs. players (day 30). Panel mean 87/100 from 9 scores; Steam 72% of 11,012.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4

Critics +50.3 percentile points vs. players (to date, day 26). Panel mean 84/100 from 10 scores; Steam 70% of 12,410.

FINAL FANTASY RESONANCE

Critics −35.4 percentile points vs. players (to date, day 26). Panel mean 79/100 from 10 scores; Steam 96% of 6,325.

Steam gap by outlet

  1. Screen Rant +6.127 games · raw +8.5
  2. Game Informer +5.928 games · raw +8.7
  3. GamesRadar+ +5.923 games · raw +8.8
  4. IGN +5.836 games · raw +6.7
  5. Eurogamer +5.222 games · raw −0.3
  6. PC Gamer +5.127 games · raw +0.2
  7. Push Square +4.734 games · raw −4.2
  8. Nintendo Life +4.331 games · raw −9.7
  9. TheGamer n too small14 games · raw +19.2
  10. Pure Xbox n too small4 games · raw +39.0
  11. VGC n too small13 games · raw +14.2
  12. Game Rant n too small13 games · raw +10.4

Percentile points; shrunk mean of (outlet score percentile − Steam day-30 percentile), same-year games. Positive means the outlet ranks games higher than players do. Muted below 15 games.

The full chart

What the record shows 2026-07-20 to 2026-11-17

Recent releases: critics vs. players 12 games

Every game with at least two scored panel reviews in the last three weeks. Critics: the mean of panel scores rescaled to 0–100, ranked as a percentile among this year's reviewed releases (needs three scores). Players: Steam's percent positive, adjusted toward the panel-wide average for small samples, ranked the same way. Gap = critic percentile − player percentile.

GameScoresCriticsSteamGapCritics ← → players
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4Activision · released 2026-10-22 10 8472nd pct 70%12,410 reviews22nd pct · to date, day 26 +50.3 ptsto date, day 26
Phantom Blade ZeroS-GAME Publishing · released 2026-10-28 10+1 unscored 8887th pct 95%118,636 reviews81st pct · to date, day 20 +6.1 ptsto date, day 20
ACE COMBAT 8: WINGS OF THEVEBandai Namco Entertainment Inc. · released 2026-10-01 9+1 unscored 8785th pct 85%18,326 reviews49th pct +35.3 pts
Castlevania: Belmont's CurseKONAMI · released 2026-10-14 9+2 unscored 7746th pct 77%9,073 reviews28th pct +17.9 pts
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TimeNintendo · released 2026-11-04 8+3 unscored 9599th pct Console exclusive —Console exclusive
TANUKI: Pon's SummerCRITICAL REFLEX · released 2026-11-10 4 7535th pct 90%98 reviews59th pct · to date, day 7 −24.3 ptsto date, day 7
Warhammer SurvivorsAuroch Digital · released 2026-11-10 4 7535th pct 65%3,247 reviews17th pct · to date, day 7 +18.2 ptsto date, day 7
Godzilla: Destroy All Monsters Melee RemasteredAtari · released 2026-11-03 3 7018th pct 95%1,607 reviews83rd pct · to date, day 14 −64.2 ptsto date, day 14
Wild Blue SkiesBalor Games · released 2026-08-13 3 501st pct 61%248 reviews10th pct −9.1 pts
Barbie RewindAtari · released 2026-11-12 2 65under 3 scores 47%42 reviews4th pct · to date, day 5 —to date, day 5
Silver PinesTeam17 · released 2026-10-08 2 85under 3 scores 96%5,246 reviews85th pct —
The Wolf Among Us RemasteredTelltale · released 2026-10-29 2 80under 3 scores 91%979 reviews65th pct · to date, day 19 —to date, day 19

Bars run right (red) when critics rank a game above players, left (blue) when players rank it higher. Steam figures are filtered for off-topic review bombs, all languages; provisional until day 30.

New panel reviews last 48 hours

  1. Review: TANUKI: Pon's Summer (Switch 2) - Cosy Postie Delivers Sick BMX Tricks & Minigames Nintendo Life · 7/10
  2. Mini Review: Tanuki: Pon's Summer (PS5) - Easily One of 2026's Most Charming Adventures Push Square · 8/10
  3. Milki Delivery Review - Possibly The Next A Short Hike Screen Rant · 8/10
  4. Ashes of the Singularity 2 review PC Gamer · 40/100

The panel

16 outlets: 13 general and 3 platform-branded. 12 publish scores we can read; 4 are counted for coverage only. Window: reviews published 2026-07-20 to 2026-11-17.

OutletGroupScaleReviews
IGNGeneral0–1063
PC GamerGeneral0–10032
GamesRadar+General0–5 stars39
EurogamerGeneral1–5 stars32
Game InformerGeneral0–1043
Game RantGeneral0–1023
TheGamerGeneral0–1026
Screen RantGeneral0–1055
VGCGeneral1–5 stars24
Push SquarePlatform: PlayStation0–1055
Nintendo LifePlatform: Nintendo0–1082
Pure XboxPlatform: Xbox0–105
Rock Paper ShotgunGeneralunscored12
KotakuGeneralunscored20
The VergeGeneralunscored10
GameSpotGeneral0–10 (not readable: bot wall)4
Total525

Reviews counted are game reviews matched to a release that at least one panel outlet scored. Not included: OpenCritic (terms bar aggregators), Metacritic (no automated access), Destructoid (bot wall), Polygon (feed unavailable). GameSpot's review pages are behind a bot wall, so it is counted from its feed only, without scores.