Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent Review Analysis Methodology · Archive

Reviewing the Reviewers

Seven Out of Ten

The panel · general outlet

GamesRadar+

Score scale 0–5 stars. 39 game reviews in the window. www.gamesradar.com

Steam gap

+5.9

Mean of (score percentile − Steam day-30 percentile), shrunk toward the panel. 90% interval +0.9 to +10.8. 23 games; raw mean +8.8. Higher than 69% of eligible outlets.

Consensus gap

−4.1

Same calculation against the mean of the other panel outlets. Within noise. 90% interval −11.3 to +3.1. 30 games; raw mean −5.5. Higher than 32% of eligible outlets.

How to read it

Scale note: this outlet uses a five-point scale, so a 3/5 counts as 60/100 and a 4/5 as 80/100. Part of any consensus gap reflects how a coarse star scale maps onto 0–100, not only how harsh or generous its critics are.

Positive: this outlet ranks games higher than players (left) or than its peers (middle). If the Steam gap is high but the consensus gap is near zero, the whole press is more generous than players, not this outlet in particular.

Robustness strip

The Steam gap recomputed with each alternative player measure. A finding counts only if its sign survives every variant with enough games.

Not distinguishable from zero (5 of 6 variants had 15+ games)

Conditional gaps

How far this outlet moves from its own baseline on a kind of game, in percentile points, shrunk toward zero. Shown only with at least 8 games. Called a "difference" unless the 90% interval excludes zero against both players and critics.

Categoryvs. Steamvs. criticsReading
Major-publisher (AAA/AA) releases+0.990%: −3.7 to +5.5 · n=19−0.390%: −4.7 to +4.0 · n=27not distinguishable from zero
Indie-tagged releasesn=2n=1not shown (fewer than 8 games)
Likely console exclusives (not on Steam)No Steam score exists for these games, so only the consensus version can be computed.—n=5not shown (fewer than 8 games)

Bylines with 8+ scored reviews

Listed alphabetically by surname, not ranked. Figures describe published reviews only. 22 other bylines with fewer than 8 scored reviews are not shown.

No byline reaches the threshold in this window.

Disclosure audit

Ethics or standards policy
About GamesRadar+ (independence and affiliate sections) (checked 2026-11-17)
States review-copy source
95% (37 of 39)
Affiliate disclosure on the page
100% (39 of 39)

Parsed from each review page's text (scripts, navigation and footer removed). "Review-copy source" means a line such as "code provided by the publisher" or "we bought our copy".

Every review in the window

Game / headlineBylineScorevs. criticsDate
World of Warcraft: ForeverWorld of Warcraft: Forever review: "A love letter to the MMORPG I fell for over 20 years ago, with familiar chJen Allen4.5/5—2026-11-11
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of TimeThe Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time review: "Pure magic – the biggest, boldest remake I've ever played"Anna Koselke5/5−0.52026-11-04
Phantom Blade ZeroPhantom Blade Zero review: "A GOTY contender with combat that looks as good as it feels"Luke Kemp4.5/5−3.22026-10-26
FINAL FANTASY RESONANCEFinal Fantasy Resonance review: "A breezy nostalgia-laced JRPG that gives the HD-2D style a shot in the arm"Alan Wen4/5+2.42026-10-20
Stupid Never DiesStupid Never Dies review: "This pop punk zombie action RPG oozes personality, but ends up dead on arrival"Alex Spencer2/5−3.12026-10-19
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 review: "Delivers a spectacular campaign, all while DMZ mode's tight loop makesJake Tucker4.5/5+11.12026-10-16
over the hillOver the Hill review: "The single most stressful game I’ve played in years and I think it hates me"Justin Towell2.5/5—2026-10-14
Castlevania: Belmont's CurseCastlevania: Belmont's Curse review: "Gothic brilliance and compellingly cryptic clues mark a triumphant returSerena Cherry4/5+8.62026-10-13
Valor MortisValor Mortis review: "First-person Souslike parrying feels clutch, but I need more for this to truly stand outAbbie Stone3/5−38.62026-10-12
Clive Barker's Hellraiser: RevivalClive Barker's Hellraiser: Revival review: "Pinhead's return is glorious – this is a true love letter to the oOscar Taylor-Kent4/5+47.32026-10-08
Silver PinesSilver Pines review: "This horror Metroidvania take on Silent Hill and Resident Evil is a mystery that's hard Max Williams4.5/5—2026-10-06
The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt — RemasteredThe Witcher 3: Wild Hunt Remastered review: "An exceptional update that refines the rough edges to make a greaHayes Madsen4.5/5−15.32026-10-02
STAR WARS: Galactic RacerStar Wars: Galactic Racer review: "True to its Burnout legacy, blisteringly fast space racing keeps me coming Will Sawyer4/5−36.32026-10-02
Gears of War: E-DayGears of War E-Day review: "Brings Gears back to the cutting edge of shooters"Andrew Brown4/5−36.32026-10-01
End of AbyssEnd of Abyss review: "Little Nightmares meets Resident Evil, but they meet at Frustration Station"Luke Kemp3/5−16.12026-09-30
TOEM 2Toem 2 review: "Effortlessly charming with clever puzzling, this photography adventure is worth snapping up"Sam Loveridge4.5/5+23.32026-09-28
Minecraft Dungeons IIMinecraft Dungeons 2 review: "This family friendly take on Diablo embraces old school vibes in the best ways"Justin Towell3.5/5+17.22026-09-28
ACE COMBAT 8: WINGS OF THEVEAce Combat 8: Wings of Theve review: "Soars thanks to thrilling dogfights and a genuinely gripping Metal Gear-Scott McCrae4.5/5+2.92026-09-25
SILENT HILL: TownfallSilent Hill Townfall review: "Unrelentingly dark and disturbing horror"Leon Hurley4.5/5+33.52026-09-21
CONTROL ResonantControl Resonant review: "Deeply weird with wondrous supernatural vistas but bafflingly dull combat"Oscar Taylor-Kent3/5−48.82026-09-18
Fire Emblem: Fortune's WeaveFire Emblem: Fortune's Weave review: "Deep tactical battles and a compelling narrative make this an ambitious Alan Wen4/5−40.42026-09-16
The clever tweaks and new mechanics in Emerland prove that it's so much more than a fresh coat of paint on EverdellThe clever tweaks and new mechanics in Emerland prove that it's so much more than a fresh coat of paint on EveScott White4.5/5—2026-09-14
Marvel's WolverineMarvel's Wolverine review: "Missing that crucial X-Factor"Leon Hurley3/5−12.12026-09-10
Duel of Meloch is a bold experiment that blends two beloved strategy board games together, but newcomers may get left behindDuel of Meloch is a bold experiment that blends two beloved strategy board games together, but newcomers may gMatt Thrower3/5—2026-09-09
My family loves board games and kaiju, so King of Tokyo: Godzilla was a day one purchase for meMy family loves board games and kaiju, so King of Tokyo: Godzilla was a day one purchase for meChristian Hoffer4/5—2026-09-02
Onimusha: Way of the SwordOnimusha: Way of the Sword review: "It's no Sekiro, but goofiness, accessibility, and tight combat help this rLuke Kemp3.5/5−46.12026-08-31
The Blood of DawnwalkerThe Blood of Dawnwalker review: "Despite clear Witcher 3 DNA, I wish this vampire RPG was messier"Oscar Taylor-Kent3/5−36.52026-08-31
Aliens: Fireteam Elite 2Aliens: Fireteam Elite 2 review: "I love this janky, deliciously imperfect bug-hunting adventure"Luke Kemp3.5/5+21.32026-08-28
Resonance: A Plague Tale LegacyResonance: A Plague Tale Legacy review: "Rivals Uncharted and Tomb Raider with a snappy sword fighting take onOscar Taylor-Kent4.5/5+51.92026-08-26
STAR WARS Zero CompanyStar Wars Zero Company review: "XCOM with lightsabers is a truly sweet deal, and it doesn't have to reinvent tAlex Spencer4/5−20.02026-08-26
Horrified: Ravenloft is a slam-dunk for D&D fans, but innovation is starting to be 'mist'Horrified: Ravenloft is a slam-dunk for D&D fans, but innovation is starting to be 'mist'Benjamin Abbott4/5—2026-08-25
The Sinking City 2The Sinking City 2 review: "A Lovecraftian fusion of Resident Evil and Silent Hill that boasts its own delightOscar Taylor-Kent4/5+30.02026-08-17
Mortal Shell IIMortal Shell 2 review: "The best Soulslike I've played since Elden Ring thanks to brilliant death-dealing toysAbbie Stone4/5−17.02026-08-17
Hell Let Loose: VietnamHell Let Loose: Vietnam review: "Often frustrating but always involving, this FPS brings war to life and bloodJoe Chivers4/5—2026-08-12
MARVEL Tōkon: Fighting SoulsMarvel Tokon: Fighting Souls review: "A stunning comeback for superhero fighters, essential for Marvel and genAlan Wen4.5/5+9.02026-08-12
Take Time is a fantastic co-op board game, so there's no surprise it wound up on the recommended list for the Spiel des JahresTake Time is a fantastic co-op board game, so there's no surprise it wound up on the recommended list for the Christian Hoffer4.5/5—2026-08-11
Beast of ReincarnationBeast of Reincarnation review: "The Pokemon dev knocks it out the park with a stunningly confident sci-fi actiLuke Kemp4.5/5+74.32026-08-04
Halo: Campaign EvolvedHalo: Campaign Evolved review: "An FPS in its purest form, but also a wasted opportunity for Halo Studios to pWill Sawyer3.5/5−42.02026-07-23
Splatoon RaidersSplatoon Raiders review: "Smartly translates Squidling vibes into a looter shooter I keep coming back to, evenLuke Kemp4/5−26.12026-07-21